Most Mumbai police stations do not have working CCTVs

Inspection of city police stations shows most of them do not have working CCTVs and those that have, circumvent SC guidelines by partitioning off interrogation areas and lock-ups away from the cameras

The keepers of the law seem to have no compunctions about flouting it themselves. Despite the 2015 SC order that made it mandatory for police stations to install CCTV cameras on their premises, especially inside interrogation rooms, quite a few police stations that mid-day visited on Monday have either not installed a single camera, or have strategically turned the cameras away from the interrogation rooms.

12

No. of police stations mid-day visited in the first part of the test drive

the CCTV camera at Navghar police station is aimed at the floor. PIC/RAJESH GUPTA

mid-day’s report on November 5

A day after mid-day’s report on Wadala TT police violating SC’s order by not installing CCTVs, officers at the police station got the entire premises under surveillance in 24 hours. As per the Supreme Court’s order, it is mandatory for all the police stations to put CCTV cameras in the interrogation rooms to prevent custodial torture and deaths. The court, back in 2015, had also given a maximum time of two years in which to do so. But, four years later, when mid-day surveyed a few other police stations in the city, here is what we found: 

2015

Year SC directed state govts to ensure all police stations installed CCTV cameras

Mulund and Vikhroli police stations

No CCTV cameras in detection rooms at Mulund. Also, no cameras installed inside the lock-up of Vikhroli police station

There are no CCTV cameras in the detection rooms at these police stations. PICS/RAJESH GUPTA

Samtanagar and Versova police stations

Versova police station. Pic/Datta Kumbhar

The police station has no proper lock-up and criminals are accommodated in a room attached to the detection office. Only the inside room has a camera.

Aarey police station

There was no CCTV visible on the premises here.  PIC/DATTA KUMBHAR

Due to space constraints, the police station has no facilities. They have less than 100 square feet space where they usually question criminals, which has no CCTV cameras in sight. Post interrogation, the accused are made to sit on a bench behind the station house that has CCTV camera.

Amboli police station

There was no CCTV visible on the premises here. PIC/DATTA KUMBHAR

The detection room has no CCTV cameras. A proper lock-up has been created inside the station house room.

Vanrai and Borivli police stations

The CCTV camera here is installed over the door leading to the lock-up. PIC/DATTA KUMBHAR

Borivli police station’s cameras face away from the interrogation rooms. PIC/DATTA KUMBHAR

The detection room here was no different from that at Charkop. The CCTV camera was installed over the door leading to the lock-up and the camera focuses only on the lock-up where the criminals are held.

Navghar police station

The CCTV camera at Navghar Police Station is aimed at the floor. PIC/RAJESH GUPTA

The CCTV camera inside the detection room has been turned away to face the floor due to which the interrogation room is not covered by surveillance.

Wadala police station

Cops here say no cameras are installed as they have shifted to a new location. PIC/SURESH KARKERA

The Wadala police station, which was shifted to BPT Colony from Korba Mitha Nagar Wadala East around six months ago, still awaits CCTV cameras on its premises. This police station has the most sensitive areas in Wadala under its jurisdiction. Senior PI Gangadhar Sonavane of Wadala police station told mid-day, “The police station was recently shifted to another location. We are still in the process of installing CCTV cameras. The cameras that allow us to survey the entire locality has already been connected to the police station. The cameras will be installed inside the police station premises soon.”

Charkop police station

The detection area is divided into two rooms. One is occupied by detection officers while the inside room has a lock-up to accommodate criminals and petty offenders. Though the locked room is covered by CCTV cameras, the place where the accused is interrogated by the officers has no cameras.

Bangur Nagar police station

There is no lock-up here and also no CCTV cameras in the detection room where they interrogate criminals.

What the SC had said
The Supreme Court in its judgment dated July 24, 2015, had given directions to all the state governments to ensure that all police stations and interrogation rooms were put under the surveillance of CCTV cameras to prevent custodial torture and deaths:

• The state governments shall take steps to install CCTV cameras in all prisons in their respective states, within a period of one year from today but not later than two years.
• The state governments shall also consider the installation of CCTV cameras in police stations in a phased manner depending upon the incidents of human rights violations reported in such stations.

Catch up on all the latest Crime, National, International and Hatke news here. Also, download the new mid-day Android and iOS apps to get latest updates

"Exciting news! Mid-day is now on WhatsApp Channels Subscribe today by clicking the link and stay updated with the latest news!" Click here!