Responding to a series of RTI queries, WR, MRVC and the Rail Designs and Standards Organisation all admit that the high-speed trial run between Mumbai and Dahanu has failed; officials remain tight-lipped
mid-day exclusive
ADVERTISEMENT
The dreams of a high-speed local train have crashed and burned. The special rake was supposed to have a running speed close to that of Gatimaan Express, India's fastest train. But after pouring Rs 60 crore and six years into building it and conducting trial runs, the railway authorities have finally admitted that the so-called high-speed train is barely faster than a regular local.
The RDSO stated that the train failed trial runs at 140 kmph because of a fault in the bogie design. Pics/Arzan Kotval
The Western Railway (WR) started testing the high-speed MRVC 1181 train in 2012, but all these years, officials remained tight-lipped on why it hadn't been pressed into service. It is only now that the authorities have responded to RTI (Right To Information) queries, admitting that the Rs 60-crore rake is a complete failure.
Also read: Indian Railways to introduce high-speed trains between Mumbai-Delhi
Mumbaikars were promised a train that would run at speeds of 140-145 kmph, close to the speed of Gatimaan Express (160 kmph). Instead, Mumbai's fastest train has been dying a slow death as it sits abandoned at the Virar car shed. Its parts have been stripped and used on other trains that are in operation. Now, the officials have decided that the rake will run at the same speed as any other local - at a humble 80 kmph.
This information came to light through a series of responses this month to a commuter activist's RTI applications to WR, the Mumbai Railway Vikas Corporation (MRVC), and the Lucknow-based Railway Designs and Standards Organisation (RDSO).
Contradictory answers
The trials were conducted between Mumbai, Virar and Dahanu, but all three organisations have given contradictory information on the number of trials conducted. WR's reply stated only that trials were conducted at variable speeds, and sanctioned speed was 145 kmph. MRVC's reply stated that two trials were conducted on the Virar-Dahanu section, and that they were not successful. This response also added that the train will be put into regular service after necessary modifications. There was no mention of the trial speed.
The reply from RDSO said that three trials were conducted, and the train failed at 140 kmph, which was the top speed for testing. RDSO's response further explained that the train failed the trial runs because of a fault in the design of the bogie (the undercarriage and wheels).
While the high-speed rake looks similar to the other locals, it is the bogie that would have made all the difference. It's frame and technology was bought from Siemens, Austria, as part of the R4,500-crore Mumbai Urban Transport Project (MUTP). The train would have cut down the travel time for longer distances to Dahanu, Karjat and Kasara by at least 20 to 25 minutes.
Dead weight
The train was rolled out by the Integral Coach Factory (ICF) in Chennai. The nine-car rake was filled with heavy bags of sand and debris during the test runs. "The bags were equal to the weight of a crowded train. Trials were conducted till a few years ago, but now the train has just been standing here," said an official at the Virar car shed. The train has now been cannibalised, as most of its functional parts, like lighting, seating and other accessories, have been used as replacements for existing running trains.
Railway officials now claim that they had only planned to conduct trials with the rake, and it was never intended to be pressed into service. "There are limitations within the city for such high-speed travel, given the back-to-back line up of the trains in the saturated suburban system and the quality of tracks. But, it is easily possible outside city limits, at the Dahanu and Kasara-Karjat stretches. However, the tracks too need to be equipped to cater to such speeds," said an official.
No officials were willing to speak on record about the project, and there was no explanation for why the authorities spent Rs 60 crore on a train that was only meant to be used for trials. It seems all the more wasteful now, considering the success of the new Bombardier rakes, which are capable of running at about 110 to 120kmph, and cost nearly Rs 10 crore less to make.
160 kmph
Speed of Gatimaan Express, the nation's fastest train
140 kmph
Speed at which the high-speed local failed
120 kmph
Speed that the Bombardier rakes are capable of
145 kmph
Speed that was promised
80 kmph
Regular speed at which the special train will now run
Download the new mid-day Android and iOS apps to get updates on all the latest and trending stories on the go
Subscribe today by clicking the link and stay updated with the latest news!" Click here!
