The complex landscape of INDIA Alliance for the 2024 Lok Sabha polls

As the dust settles on the recent state elections, the INDIA alliance finds itself at crossroads, grappling with internal dissent, Congress's electoral setbacks, and the daunting task of countering the BJP's dominance in the upcoming 2024 Lok Sabha polls. The unexpected proposal of Mallikarjun Kharge as the prime ministerial candidate has added another layer of complexity to an already intricate political landscape.

The INDIA bloc, a formidable coalition of regional parties united against the BJP, convened in Delhi on Tuesday for a pivotal meeting. At the heart of the discussions was the proposal of Mallikarjun Kharge as the coalition's prime ministerial candidate. While Kharge's credentials are notable, a consensus within the alliance remains elusive, highlighting the challenges that lie ahead.

West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee and Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal spearheaded Kharge's nomination during the meeting, emphasising his caste, experience, and proximity to the Gandhis as factors contributing to his credibility. However, Kharge, maintaining a pragmatic stance, urged the alliance to prioritise victory in the elections before deliberating on the prime ministerial face.

The aftermath of the recent state elections, particularly the Congress's setbacks in Madhya Pradesh, Chhattisgarh, and Rajasthan, has injected a sense of urgency and tension within the INDIA alliance. The Congress, traditionally a key player in Indian politics, now faces its worst-ever footprint in North India, limiting its presence to Himachal Pradesh. The party's performance has triggered internal dissent and a reassessment of its role within the alliance.

The Congress's decision to stall the activities of the INDIA alliance in the run-up to the Assembly elections has irked alliance members, disrupting the momentum gained since its formation in June. There is a prevailing sentiment among allies that the Congress hindered seat-sharing negotiations with regional parties, hoping for a strong showing in the elections to strengthen its position in future talks.

Read Also: Unravelling Kashmir's political landscape post Supreme Court's Article 370 verdict

Senior Janata Dal (United) leader K C Tyagi expressed disappointment about the election results, stating, "This is the defeat of the Congress. We are sorry that it happened just before the Lok Sabha elections. This is not the defeat of the INDIA alliance."

Tyagi criticised the overenthusiasm and overconfidence of Congress party, highlighting the need for INDIA alliance parties to unite with new methods to take on the BJP.
Trinamool Congress (TMC) spokesperson Kunal Ghosh attributed the Congress's losses more to internal failures than a BJP success story. He emphasised that the TMC could provide leadership in the battle against the BJP, underlining the growing discontent within the alliance regarding the Congress's leadership.

The Arvind Kejriwal-led Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) wasted no time in claiming the position of the largest Opposition party in North India after the election results. Senior AAP leader Jasmine Shah asserted, "After today's results, Aam Aadmi Party emerged as the largest Opposition party in north India with two state governments - Punjab and Delhi."

The Congress's wipeout in the Hindi heartland has positioned it as the "weakest link" within the INDIA alliance, according to some leaders. The burden of upholding the alliance now falls on regional parties such as the DMK and the Trinamool Congress, who are expected to deliver strong performances. One leader remarked, "It is an irony that the party which claims itself as the leader of the alliance is the weakest link."

As the alliance grapples with internal challenges and the Congress faces a crisis of identity, the path to the 2024 Lok Sabha polls appears fraught with uncertainties. The proposal of Mallikarjun Kharge as the prime ministerial candidate, while showcasing the alliance's diversity, also underscores the inherent complexities and divergent interests within its fold.

Political commentator K.M. Chandrasekhar, reflecting on the state elections, emphasised the lessons learned and the emerging political dynamics. He highlighted the sharp divide in India's political choices, with a discernible north-south divide. The Modi factor, while dominant in the north, did not yield the same results in Karnataka and Telangana, where the Congress emerged as a viable alternative.

Chandrasekhar suggests that the Congress's state-level leadership in the Hindi-speaking belt may not pose a significant threat to the BJP, given the overwhelming influence of the Modi image. To navigate these challenges, he suggests that the leadership of the INDIA alliance should be entrusted to a Hindi-speaking leader with administrative and political experience, citing Nitish Kumar as a potential candidate.

The regional dynamics also come into play, with leaders like Mamata Banerjee in the east and Naveen Patnaik in Odisha. The Congress's aversion to Arvind Kejriwal in Delhi and Punjab is questioned, signalling the need for strategic alliances to counter the BJP's stronghold.

In the south, despite the Congress's setbacks in state elections, the party, under Rahul Gandhi and Mallikarjun Kharge, is urged to assume leadership. Kerala remains a unique case, with the BJP's limited representation, but the UDF and LDF are advised to continue their political battles, except in constituencies where the BJP poses a credible threat.

Despite the challenges, Chandrasekhar warns against underestimating the power of the Modi factor in national elections. The INDIA alliance's ability to significantly reduce the BJP's majority in parliament is deemed crucial for its long-term survival. The impending parliamentary delimitation after 2026 adds another layer of complexity, with potential implications for Indian polity and governance.

As the INDIA alliance grapples with internal dissent, strategic recalibration, and the Congress's identity crisis, its ability to present a united front against the BJP in the 2024 Lok Sabha polls remains a subject of intense scrutiny.