Mumbai: Guardian minister pledges review of hefty fine for banned plastic

Civic activists have proposed that BMC consider revising the fine structure. File pic

Mumbai Suburban Guardian Minister Mangal Prabhat Lodha, in conversation with mid-day, pledged to review the hefty Rs 5000 penalty imposed on end-users of banned plastic. Meanwhile, civic activists have proposed that the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) consider revising the fine structure.

Speaking to mid-day, Lodha stated, "I will examine this matter concerning fines, but I cannot immediately assure any changes to the fine. However, I will engage in discussions with BMC officials. I must grasp the intricacies of the issue and subsequently confer with senior officials."

According to a state government notification dated March 23, 2018, the BMC holds the authority to take action against citizens utilising prohibited plastic and thermocol. The regulations entail a fine of Rs 5,000 for first-time offenders, Rs 15,000 for second-time offenders, and Rs 25,000 for third-time offenders, with a potential three-month imprisonment for the latter.

Mangal Prabhat Lodha, Mumbai suburban guardian minister

Activist Anil Galgali said, "Yes, the fine is exorbitant. There's a potential for corruption. BMC must implement video recording of enforcement actions." Another civic activist, Nikhil Desai, also opined that the fine is on the higher end. He emphasised that not only the general public but even street vendors would struggle to afford a Rs 5000 fine.

Activist Sanjay Gurav proposed that fines should differ based on whether one is a stockist, seller, or involved in production. He stressed that while it's crucial to maintain a substantial fine, the amount should be determined in accordance with the user.

BMC officials, speaking anonymously, acknowledged that the fine is indeed quite high. Consequently, they cautioned that taking action against ordinary citizens could lead to controversy. However, they clarified that the state government establishes this fine structure, implying that only the government holds the power to reduce the fine. Meanwhile, BMC sezied 86.12 kilogram plastic and collected Rs 2.30 lakh fine on Wednesday.